Preliminary results of an experiment conducted at the University of Illinois indicate the possibility of selecting pigs that can make efficient use of energy in less expensive feed ingredients, thus reducing diet costs.
Less expensive feed is usually higher in fiber than the corn-soy diets typically used in U.S. swine production, explains Hans H. Stein, professor of animal sciences at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. However, the white breeds that are used in commercial pork production use only about 40% of the insoluble fiber. “If you can increase that number to 50 or 60 or 70%, then of course, you would get a much better use of the energy in those ingredients," Stein says.
“The white breeds have been selected for high efficiency and rapid gain for many, many generations," Stein says. “But that's all based on corn-soy diets. However, there are also indigenous breeds of pigs that have not been selected for commercial production, and these breeds have, therefore, not been fed the corn-soybean meal diets for as many generations as the white breeds.”
Among those indigenous breeds are Meishan pigs, which have been raised in China for many centuries. Stein's hypothesis was that these pigs, which have not been selected for efficiency and rapid weight gain, would use fiber more efficiently than the white breeds.
Stein and his team compared the fiber digestion of Meishan pigs with that of two groups of Yorkshire pigs. They tested four diets that used high-fiber ingredients: distiller’s dried grains with solubles (DDGS), soybean hulls, sugar beet pulp and pectin. When fed DDGS, the values for apparent total tract energy digestibility were higher for the Meishan pigs (83.5%) than for either weight-matched (77.3%) or age-matched (78.8%) Yorkshire pigs. Researchers observed no significant difference in energy digestibility for the other ingredients.
“What we observed was that, particularly for the DDGS diets, the Meishans were quite a bit more effective at using that fiber," Stein says. “That diet is high in insoluble dietary fiber. When we looked at more soluble fibers, there was no difference.”
Although Meishan pigs would never be used for commercial pork production in the United States, the results indicate that differences exist among breeds of pigs. Thus, it is possible that differences also exist among the white breeds and that some may use fibers more efficiently than others.
Stein stresses that this study was preliminary and that determining if white breeds can be bred to use insoluble fiber more efficiently will be quite costly because it requires selecting pigs for multiple generations. Stein says that he and colleagues at the University of Illinois' Institute for Genomic Biology are pursuing funding for further research.
“I think it is exciting that there are some pigs that can use fiber better than we have thought in the past, and I think this will open up opportunities to think in different ways about how we can feed pigs economically,” he says.
The study was published in a recent issue of the Journal of Animal Science and was co-authored with former graduate student Pedro Urriola.